Amazon's streaming platform, Prime Video, carries a significant challenge: to develop a fantasy series that reaches the monumental heights of the former television titan, Game of Thrones. Competing fiercely, HBO has House of the Dragon, a prequel with inherent advantages due to its connection to the original series. However, Amazon counters with its own ambitious prequel, The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, which boasts an impressive production budget that is evident in every frame. Now, the series is set for its second season.
The primary objective for Prime Video is to elevate the fantasy genre while appealing to both avid fans and newcomers. Game of Thrones achieved widespread acclaim by attracting viewers fascinated by epic tales, mythical creatures, and unexpected violence set in fantastical realms reminiscent of medieval England, as well as those who typically shy away from such themes. In contrast, another of Amazon's fantasy endeavors, The Wheel of Time, has struggled to connect with a broader audience. The Rings of Power, however, adopts a different approach, believing that the extensive Rings franchise can attract both devoted fans and mainstream viewers.
Season one largely focused on foreshadowing and subtle references, introducing younger versions of familiar characters alongside others who hinted at future significance. The central mystery was the identity of Sauron, whose true form was masked throughout the season, prompting speculation and intrigue among viewers. As the series progressed, the question shifted to his whereabouts and whom he might be deceiving.
Despite facing the inherent challenge of presenting a lore-heavy narrative, The Rings of Power finds moments of excitement, particularly through the cunning strategies of its characters. However, the dialogue often consists of exposition, revealing past events and dire predictions, which might alienate casual viewers. The show's elves, with their exaggerated accents when mentioning significant places, add to the challenge of making the fantasy world accessible.
Nevertheless, the series shines in its production quality. The depiction of a massive spider or a horde of orcs is both convincing and visually impressive. Elements like waterfalls, volcanic eruptions, and explosive battles are rendered with spectacular detail, though the series could benefit from more action sequences.
The Harfoots, reminiscent of hobbits, offer charm with their quirky accents, while the dwarves bring humor and memorable phrases. Leading the narrative is Galadriel, played by Morfydd Clark, whose development as a warrior contrasts with her past naivety regarding Sauron's true nature. Although there are rewarding moments of drama, the series occasionally struggles under the weight of its connections to the original lore. As it stands, The Rings of Power may find it challenging to break new ground while remaining too entrenched in its established legacy.